OK, I'm trying to follow you on this one - You say the issue of negotiations was brought up by the FOP. You would be correct. The FOP correctly felt that charging a fee for the take home car was something to be brought up in contract negotiations, not at the whim of the mayor. However, the mayor violated fair labor practices in taking that money out in the first place. It should have be negotiated FIRST, not taken from you, and then you be forced to negotiate it after the fact. There should be NO