Officer Mattingly's review came from the chief's axe boys- Sgt. Sean Jackman and Lt. Mueller. Of course, the chief through in his two cents, too. The review board did not decide his fate. Are you referring to the Mayor's Citzens Committee for Police Accountability? One of the potential jurors for Mattingly's case sits on this committee- hand picked by the mayor. This person was stricken for basically stating they could not be fair towards Mattingly. This person made blatantly antipolice comments.