I see there are still those who would ****** and complain no matter what happens. If you don't want to pay the money for using it off duty then DON'T. No one is forcing you to use it. I know now you are going to cry that I need it for my off duty jobs so I can pay my bills. If that is the case you need to start living on what you make at the department and use off duty as your bonus. It appears that you cannot be happy that they are going to give everyone back the money that was taken from them